Mama’s Challah

Mama’s challah. Or as my mom calls it: “the BEST challah.” And she’s right. The recipe from start to finish takes time (approximately 3 hours) so I either make it Thursday night or Friday afternoon when I get home. I prefer making it Friday so it’s fresh and warm out of oven; Here’s the secret: you spread a little butter, sprinkle a little salt and you’ve got heaven on earth in the shape of braided bread. Since this makes two loaves we usually have one plain and one raisin. And as anyone who’s anyone knows, challah makes the best french toast and/or peanut butter and jelly sandwiches.


Source: Mama

7 cups all-purpose or bread flour
½ cup brown sugar + 2 tsp. granulated sugar
2 packages regular yeast
2 1/4 cup water
2 tsp. salt
½ cup vegetable oil
3 eggs

1. Mix in tall glass: 3 T. flour, 2 tsp. sugar, both packages of yeast. Stir mixture slightly then add ¾ cup lukewarm water (100-115. measure using liquid thermometer) Let this bubble & “rise” to brim of glass for about 10 minutes. (NOTE: This should bubble up to the top. If it doesn’t start to foam within in a few minutes, try again with warmer water.) In the meantime….
2. In medium bowl (bowl A), combine 3 cups flour and 2 tsp. salt
3. In larger bowl (bowl B) whisk together brown sugar, oil, 2 eggs
4. Pour contents from bowl “A” into bowl “B”
5. Add contents of glass into bowl “B”
6. Add another 1 ½ cups lukewarm water (110-115 degrees) into bowl “B”
7. Add 4 more cups flour into bowl “B”
8. Mix everything with wooden spoon at quick pace! When it’s too thick to mix with spoon, transfer dough to floured wooden board or other surface for about 5 minutes.
9. Keep hands floured, add small amounts flour by hand when dough gets sticky. It should be smooth…not too loose, not too, firm, not too sticky. Scrap off bits of dough from board, so surface is clean, & smooth. Form into a round.
10. Lightly oil another large bowl, place dough in bowl, turn over to coat with oil.Cover bowl with lightly damp towel.
11. Have warm oven ready (NOTE: preheat oven to 150 then turn off before putting dough in)
12. Place bowl in oven for 45 minutes / 1 hour. At 45 minutes check to see if doubled in size.
13. Remove bowl from oven, dip fist into flour, very gently punch 10-12 times to punch out air.
14. Knead again on floured board 5 minutes, add a bit of oil to bowl again, make round; return dough to bowl, cover, return to oven, let rise again 30/40ish minutes.
15. Punch down again, knead into a round. Gently divide into 2 loaves with sharp knife… do not saw. Pre-heat oven to 350.
16. Place 1 loaf aside in bowl. With remaining loaf, knead with 1 hand into ball (NOTE: if using raisins, add them here), then divide into 3 pieces, braid on lightly floured board. Roll out, fatter in middle, skinny on ends of each rope. Pinch ends together, tuck under. Repeat with other loaf.
17. Place on oiled cookie sheet. Make egg wash – mix 1 egg & a bit of water, brush over loaves. Bake 30 minutes.


15 Comments Add yours

  1. julia freifeld says:

    Emily, you are the apple of my eye!! hey, that’s a good expression to use with a “foodie”

    I hope your readers enjoy the recipe because it is the BEST recipe :))

    I love you, you are the BEST!!


  2. Dad says:

    Emily – I love this Challah! It also makes a great toasted bread for a squish sandwich. Toast bread then assemble: bread-slice of cheese-bread– squish!!

    Love Dad
    P.S. This recipe is a secret

  3. Emily says:

    Oh dad now the whole world knows! Well, it’s better that way. Then they too can enjoy the delight of a squished cheese sandwich 🙂

  4. This looks REALLY yummy. Thanks to you and to your mom (hey, Emily’s dad, sorry about the secret, but you raised a daughter who shares)……………..

    Happy Thanksgiving!

  5. Emily says:

    Thanks Tinky! Happy Thanksgiving to you too!

  6. Katie says:

    I agree! This was DEFINITELY the best challah! Thanks so much for the recipe!!

  7. I once shared a house with a crazy baker, who made the best Challah bread. I’ve since lost his recipe and acquaintance, so I’m eager to try your recipe. Looks delicious and substantial — as bread should be. thanks!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s